Ah, it’s February and romance is in the air….
Not so much if you’re a single, romance author—then the romance is all in your head! But as a romance author, I’m delighted to be here this month and celebrate that all important human emotion with all of you.
One of my favorite movies is He Said, She Said. When Terri-Lynne said I could piggy-back off
one of the authors blog posts here, I couldn’t resist taking the opportunity to
use that He Said, She Said approach and tag onto her thoughts about the
happily-ever after and what constitutes romance.
Let me start with why romance (and across any genre)
appeals. I think it is because that is a
human emotion that everyone relates to.
In non-romance genres, I think you see more of a “loss” of loving
couples, so to speak, and heartbreak, because those emotions are even more
powerful than the bliss of being in love.
As such, it’s natural to include it in plot arcs.
But when you start talking about genre romance, you start
dealing with an entirely different core plot.
Compared to fantasy where the storyline often trends toward the
“hero-quest” approach, a genre-romance isn’t so much about whether the demons
are going to overtake the world, or whether the main character is going to
escape the pandemic set upon the land.
The focus of a romance novel is the hero/heroine romantic involvement,
and everything external has to contribute to that developing relationship.
The typical romance
reader has a set of expectations the novel must meet, and when those
expectations aren’t fulfilled, the reader has some…shall we say pretty
strong…reactions. One of those
expectations is a Happily Ever After or Happily For Now resolution. The hero or heroine can’t die in the end,
otherwise the focus of building their relationship through however many pages
is…pointless.
Let’s look at my other favorite movie, Message In A Bottle –
Nicholas Sparks. We have a wonderful love story. But as I step back and dry my eyes from that
gut-wrenching journey, that story isn’t about two people falling in love. It’s about a man who has to be able to
overcome his past. The story is the
hero’s journey. The heroine is merely
his inciting action. If you look at her
life throughout the movie…nothing much changes.
She’s in a slightly better place at the end, than where she was at the
beginning.
We love the hero’s journey because what he does to become a
better man is so terribly emotional.
When we reach the end, and are sobbing because he’s not going to get the
girl (or the girl isn’t going to get him), we’re also able to see that he died
a stronger person, one who didn’t live in his shadows, and had come to peace
with himself.
That’s more like women’s fiction…only with a sexy, brooding
male main character instead of a quirky, smart heroine.
So what constitutes romance? That wholly depends on how you define
it. If you choose to define it as what
we all encounter in our daily lives, it can be present in any novel, in any
form. If you choose to define it as a genre romance, then yes, the expectations
are boy meets girl, boy gets girl, boy loses girl, boy gets girl in the
end.
As someone who writes across a variety of genres –
historical fiction, romance, erotic romance, thrillers, and fantasy – romance
is fun, no matter how you use it in writing. (Gee what better way to make a reader
empathize with a character than to rip out his heart by killing his loved one
in front of him?) I love to plot and
subplot, and subplot some more, and I don’t like having everything resolved all
nice and tidy at the end, even if my hero and heroine have achieved their
HEA. I write in the other genres so I
don’t have to maintain that standard when I don’t feel it fits the story
running around in my head.
So that’s my three cents!
And I’d love to hear your questions or thoughts on them!
3 comments:
My post about HEA was sparked by Claire Delacroix's story, "An Eligy for Melusine," which did not end happily, or even happily enough--and yet it was in a collection of romance tales. But...but...but...I thought to be a romance, it HAD to have an HEA, or HFN!
It seems, as you say, that's the rule, though there are exceptions. I suppose I'll have to be satisfied with that.
Thanks for coming, Claire!
Thanks for having me here today! You all have a wonderfully entertaining blog!
Great topic Claire. Another example to consider is Night in Rodanthe also by Nicholas Sparks. There is romance in the story, but it's more about the main characters coming to grips with their individual demons - and that they do it together is what I consider the heart of the story. So sad when the hero dies, but seeing the heroine invigorated by the direction her life has taken as a result of her love for the hero is inspiring. The true love story is the one the heroine ends up in with herself.
I really enjoyed your thoughts on this topic.
Post a Comment